Back to Blog

How to Choose FP&A Software

Solver | Choosing FP&A Software for Mid-Market Teams: A Guide

You run finance at a mid-market company, the budget lives in linked workbooks emailed between department heads, and you have been asked to shortlist financial planning and analysis (FP&A) software before the next planning cycle. A wrong choice costs more than a subscription: it can mean a stalled implementation, models that only a consultant can change, and another budget season rebuilt in Excel.

The right choice comes down to fit: your ERP, your data, your planning process and your team's capacity to run the tool. This guide gives you the evaluation criteria, the questions to put to vendors and partners, and a scorecard, so you can test that fit with your own data instead of counting features.

What does FP&A software do for a mid-market finance team?

FP&A software runs planning (budgeting and forecasting), reporting, consolidation, and analysis on one governed data set, so the budget, the forecast and the monthly report all draw on the same numbers.

Many platforms also handle multi-entity financial consolidation, but not all of them do. Decide early whether you need this functionality, because that changes the shortlist.

That single data set is what separates FP&A software from the tools you already have. Your ERP's reports summarize transactions that have been recorded, while FP&A software sets plans, forecasts and scenarios against those actuals, often with data from CRM, payroll or operational systems. Spreadsheets can do the same work, and most teams still lean on them: 96% of the 362 practitioners in the AFP 2025 FP&A Benchmarking Survey used them for planning. The trouble is that every copy becomes its own version.

That version problem is usually the first sign a team is ready for dedicated software. You are probably there when several of these apply:

  • The annual budget takes about two months or longer. The AFP 2026 survey of 332 practitioners put the average at 8.7 weeks, unchanged from three years earlier.
  • Consolidating entities means copying trial balances into a master workbook.
  • Meetings start with a debate over which file is final.
  • Leadership asks questions you can only answer after month-end.

What should you decide before you look at FP&A vendors?

Write down your requirements before the first demo, or each vendor will define them for you. Answer these five questions in a one-page brief:

  1. Which processes are in scope? Annual budgeting, rolling forecasts (a forecast that extends the horizon as each period closes, combining updated actuals with revised assumptions), consolidation and management reporting each change the shortlist.
  2. Who will build and maintain models? Name the person. If nobody on staff can own changes, budget for a partner to help.
  3. How many entities, currencies and accounting standards? Count legal entities, functional currencies, charts of accounts and any GAAP and IFRS adjustments.
  4. Which source systems feed the plan? List the ERP and version, plus CRM, payroll, HR systems, and any other key data sources.
  5. What is the timeline and internal capacity? Note the date the first budget must run in the new tool and the hours your team can give the project each week.

Which capabilities matter most when you evaluate FP&A software?

ERP connectivity determines which actuals your team can load, while model design determines who can change reports and budget forms after go-live. Each criterion below ends with questions to put to every vendor on your shortlist.

How well does it connect to your ERP and other data?

A pre-built connector is a predefined connection to an ERP. A custom build is an integration your team or partner writes against the ERP's APIs and then maintains. The pre-built route saves that development work, but only for the ERPs and modules it covers.

The ERP itself sets limits too. The Microsoft Dynamics 365 Business Central documentation states that the API is the only supported read option for Business Central Online, and other ERPs cap how many API requests a connector can make each minute. Those limits shape how often data can refresh.

  1. Is the connector certified for our ERP version and modules, and who maintains it after ERP updates?
  2. What is the documented refresh frequency, and how are failed loads logged and reported?
  3. Which non-GL sources (CRM, payroll, operational data) load without a custom project?

Can your team build and change reports and models without consultants?

This decides your long-term cost more than any feature. Excel-based design lets finance managers build reports and input forms with formulas they already know. Proprietary designers use the vendor's own modeling language, which can be powerful but usually requires certified specialists. Either way, watch for key-person risk: if only one specialist can change the model, every reorganization waits on that person.

  1. Show us a finance user adding a new account to a report and a driver to a budget form. How long did it take?
  2. Which changes require a consultant or your support team?
  3. What training gets a new user productive, and how long does it take?

Does it cover planning, reporting and consolidation together?

A platform runs all three on one data set, while point tools split them across products with integrations between them. Consolidation is where the difference shows: aggregating data from multiple general ledgers, translating currencies, eliminating intercompany transactions and producing results at group and subgroup levels. For a Financial Controller, each of those steps either runs in the tool or runs in a workbook at month-end.

  1. Demonstrate translation for an entity with a different functional currency, including where the cumulative translation adjustment lands.
  2. How are intercompany eliminations configured, and how do you handle partially owned subsidiaries and noncontrolling interests?
  3. Can entities on different ERPs or charts of accounts consolidate without migrating their data?

How does the data model handle detail and growth?

Planning tools store data in one of two broad ways. A relational design keeps facts in tables joined to descriptive tables for accounts, departments and dates; data architects call this a relational SQL star schema. A multidimensional design precalculates data into a cube, called an OLAP cube, that answers summary questions quickly.

Neither design wins outright. Star schemas suit large data sets where you need the transaction detail, cubes suit smaller ones where the tool runs complex comparisons quickly, and some products combine the two. The trade-off shows up in how far you can drill down, the effort to add a dimension, and calculation speed at your volume.

  1. Show a drill-down from a variance on the P&L to the underlying transactions.
  2. What does adding a new dimension, such as a product line, involve after go-live?
  3. Can you show performance on a data volume like ours, rather than a demo data set?

What do its AI features actually do?

Judge AI by the workflow it speeds up and the data it reads. In a Gartner survey of 183 CFOs published in 2026, 84% of finance organizations had implemented or planned AI, yet only 7% reported a high or very high impact.

That gap between adoption and impact is why you need a baseline. Before funding an AI feature, record baseline forecast cycle time, time to detect and explain a variance, analyst hours on commentary, and forecast accuracy for comparison with the same measures after use. An analysis feature can flag anomalies, trends and potential drivers; an analyst still validates each finding and decides what happens next.

  1. Is our data used to train the vendor's models, and how long are prompts retained?
  2. Does the AI respect each user's existing data permissions?
  3. Can every AI finding be traced to the report line behind it, and what review step comes before anything is shared?

What will security, controls and audit trail look like?

Request the vendor's attestations and confirm what they cover. A SOC 1 report covers controls relevant to your own internal control over financial reporting, while a SOC 2 report covers security, availability, processing integrity, confidentiality or privacy. A Type 2 report adds an opinion on whether those controls operated effectively over a period. None of them is a blanket answer: the report has to cover the product and the hosting environment you will rely on.

  1. Which SOC reports and ISO/IEC 27001:2022 certificate do you hold, and do they cover this product and hosting environment?
  2. Will you provide a bridge letter for the gap period, and which complementary user entity controls must we run?
  3. Does the audit trail log configuration and administrator changes, plus who approved each access change?

How do implementation and partners affect the choice?

Implementation effort depends on your data more than the software. BARC's implementation research reports that 80% of companies take between one and twelve months from purchase to initial rollout of planning, and the state of your data usually decides where in that range you land.

The other variable is who does the work. When you buy through an ERP reseller or implementation partner, the partner's staffing matters as much as the product. Support after go-live is where projects most often come up short, so agree on a longer, outcome-based hypercare period before you sign. In one Microsoft transition-to-support case study, hypercare hours meant to last four to six weeks ran out within two.

Ask each partner these questions:

  1. Who on your team builds version one, and can we meet them before signing?
  2. What starting content (report templates, budget forms, dashboards) comes with the project?
  3. How is knowledge transferred so our team can make routine changes?
  4. What support follows go-live, under what service levels, and how are change requests billed?

How should you run the evaluation?

A disciplined process protects you from a polished demo. Run it in five steps:

  1. Finalize requirements. Use the one-page brief from earlier as the basis for every vendor conversation.
  2. Shortlist three vendors. More than three dilutes your team's attention during demos.
  3. Run a scripted demo on your data. Give every vendor the same demo script and the same scorecard so they are compared on equal terms, and ask for a proof of concept with your own data at realistic volumes. Have each one rebuild a real report, such as your consolidated P&L.
  4. Call references. Ask for customers in your industry, on your ERP, at your entity count, at least a year past go-live.
  5. Score and decide. Have each evaluator score independently, then compare.

Weight usability, performance, integration and scalability above a long feature list. The weights below are a starting point to adjust for your priorities:

Criterion

Weight

ERP and Industry solutions data connectivity

25%

Ability to build and change models in-house

20%

Planning, reporting and consolidation coverage

20%

Implementation effort and partner support

15%

Data model, detail and scale

10%

Security, controls and AI governance

10%

Then compare total cost of ownership over three to five years, not the subscription alone. Count these cost lines:

  • Software licenses and usage-based fees
  • Implementation, data integration and model building
  • Internal time from finance, IT and department heads
  • Testing, training and change management
  • Ongoing administration, support and add-on modules

What mistakes do mid-market teams make when choosing FP&A software?

Most failed selections trace back to a handful of avoidable errors:

  • Buying for features never used: Teams pay for and configure modules outside their brief, which lengthens implementation without improving the budget cycle.
  • Underestimating data preparation: In the AFP 2025 survey, 61% of respondents named data reliability as a challenge and 60% named data accessibility, and the AFP called bad data a bigger hindrance than people skills or tools.
  • Ignoring who maintains it: A model nobody on staff can change becomes a consultant invoice every time the business reorganizes.
  • Choosing an enterprise suite the team cannot staff: Midsize organizations rarely have the IT staff to customize and run a large enterprise package.
  • Skipping the partner question: Signing before meeting the implementation team leaves post-go-live support, knowledge transfer and change-request billing undefined.

Where the Solver xFP&A platform fits

Solver is an AI-accelerated extended financial planning and analysis (xFP&A) platform for mid-market teams. The platform covers planning (budgeting and forecasting), reporting, consolidation and analysis in one multi-tenant cloud on Microsoft Azure.

  • Reports are built in a native, Excel-based report writer with a web report viewer, and budget input forms run in a native Excel add-in, so finance teams keep the formulas they know. Behind that interface, data sits in the Solver Data Warehouse on a relational SQL star schema rather than OLAP cubes, with one audit trail and approval workflow across contributors and entities. Teams can add an account or dimension, including after an acquisition, without rebuilding the model, and queries run directly against current data without cube processing. That structure also makes the data well suited to AI analysis.
  • Financial consolidation covers currency translation, intercompany elimination rules, multiple charts of accounts and IFRS to GAAP adjustments across majority and minority owned businesses, with an audit trail and controlled access. For entities on different ERPs, ERP Consolidator maps each subsidiary’s general ledger to a corporate chart of accounts without migrating their data. It is included with the Solver Platform at no additional license cost and is implemented with consulting services.
  • QuickStart integrations deliver day-one reports, dashboards and budget forms for Acumatica, Microsoft Dynamics 365 Business Central, Microsoft Dynamics 365 Finance, Microsoft Dynamics 365 Sales & Service, Sage Intacct, HubSpot and Salesforce.
  • Other ERPs, including Oracle NetSuite and SAP Business One, connect through pre-built connectors into the Solver Data Warehouse, which can also load CRM, payroll, and other important data sources.
  • The Template Marketplace adds industry reports and planning templates.

Solver Copilot includes AI capabilities, such as the Help Agent and the Analysis Agent. The Help Agent gives users step-by-step guidance drawn from the platform's help, support and training content, while the Analysis Agent can identify anomalies, trends and potential drivers; users can easily validate each finding and decide what to do next. It runs on OpenAI GPT models inside a Microsoft Azure environment under SOC 2 controls, never uses user input to train the models, and works within each user's existing report permissions. The platform can be implemented in multiple ways, including Solver Consulting, self-paced training through Solver Academy, or through a global network of trusted ERP partners who know your industry.

Before your first demo, pick one real report and one budget form, write down how long each takes your team today, and ask your ERP vendor or partner for a walkthrough that rebuilds both on your own data.

To prepare for those walkthroughs, download the Guide to Choosing the Best Extended Financial Planning and Analysis (xFP&A) Solution.

How long does FP&A software implementation take?

BARC's research shows that 80% of companies take between one and twelve months from purchase to initial rollout. Your team's implementation timeline depends most on data readiness, entity count and process scope. A narrow first phase, such as budgeting only, goes live faster than budgeting plus consolidation.

Do we still use Excel?

Usually, yes. Many platforms keep Excel as the place where teams design reports and enter budgets, while storing the data centrally, so formulas stay familiar and versions stop multiplying. Ask each vendor whether you design with native Excel formulas or a proprietary modeling language, and whether every change made in Excel is logged to a central audit trail and routed through approvals.

When is a team too small for FP&A software?

There is no fixed size threshold. The better test is whether anyone on staff can own the model after go-live. If budgets are simple and one entity reports from one ERP, that may be enough.

How is FP&A software different from the ERP's reporting?

ERP reporting summarizes recorded transactions in the general ledger. FP&A software adds budgets, forecasts and scenarios against those actuals, combines data from beyond the ERP, and often consolidates multiple entities. The ERP remains the system of record.

TAGS: Reporting, Fp&a, Xfp&a