You run finance at a mid-market company, the budget lives in linked workbooks emailed between department heads, and you have been asked to shortlist financial planning and analysis (FP&A) software before the next planning cycle. A wrong choice costs more than a subscription: it can mean a stalled implementation, models that only a consultant can change, and another budget season rebuilt in Excel.
The right choice comes down to fit: your ERP, your data, your planning process and your team's capacity to run the tool. This guide gives you the evaluation criteria, the questions to put to vendors and partners, and a scorecard, so you can test that fit with your own data instead of counting features.
FP&A software runs planning (budgeting and forecasting), reporting, consolidation, and analysis on one governed data set, so the budget, the forecast and the monthly report all draw on the same numbers.
Many platforms also handle multi-entity financial consolidation, but not all of them do. Decide early whether you need this functionality, because that changes the shortlist.
That single data set is what separates FP&A software from the tools you already have. Your ERP's reports summarize transactions that have been recorded, while FP&A software sets plans, forecasts and scenarios against those actuals, often with data from CRM, payroll or operational systems. Spreadsheets can do the same work, and most teams still lean on them: 96% of the 362 practitioners in the AFP 2025 FP&A Benchmarking Survey used them for planning. The trouble is that every copy becomes its own version.
That version problem is usually the first sign a team is ready for dedicated software. You are probably there when several of these apply:
Write down your requirements before the first demo, or each vendor will define them for you. Answer these five questions in a one-page brief:
ERP connectivity determines which actuals your team can load, while model design determines who can change reports and budget forms after go-live. Each criterion below ends with questions to put to every vendor on your shortlist.
A pre-built connector is a predefined connection to an ERP. A custom build is an integration your team or partner writes against the ERP's APIs and then maintains. The pre-built route saves that development work, but only for the ERPs and modules it covers.
The ERP itself sets limits too. The Microsoft Dynamics 365 Business Central documentation states that the API is the only supported read option for Business Central Online, and other ERPs cap how many API requests a connector can make each minute. Those limits shape how often data can refresh.
This decides your long-term cost more than any feature. Excel-based design lets finance managers build reports and input forms with formulas they already know. Proprietary designers use the vendor's own modeling language, which can be powerful but usually requires certified specialists. Either way, watch for key-person risk: if only one specialist can change the model, every reorganization waits on that person.
A platform runs all three on one data set, while point tools split them across products with integrations between them. Consolidation is where the difference shows: aggregating data from multiple general ledgers, translating currencies, eliminating intercompany transactions and producing results at group and subgroup levels. For a Financial Controller, each of those steps either runs in the tool or runs in a workbook at month-end.
Planning tools store data in one of two broad ways. A relational design keeps facts in tables joined to descriptive tables for accounts, departments and dates; data architects call this a relational SQL star schema. A multidimensional design precalculates data into a cube, called an OLAP cube, that answers summary questions quickly.
Neither design wins outright. Star schemas suit large data sets where you need the transaction detail, cubes suit smaller ones where the tool runs complex comparisons quickly, and some products combine the two. The trade-off shows up in how far you can drill down, the effort to add a dimension, and calculation speed at your volume.
Judge AI by the workflow it speeds up and the data it reads. In a Gartner survey of 183 CFOs published in 2026, 84% of finance organizations had implemented or planned AI, yet only 7% reported a high or very high impact.
That gap between adoption and impact is why you need a baseline. Before funding an AI feature, record baseline forecast cycle time, time to detect and explain a variance, analyst hours on commentary, and forecast accuracy for comparison with the same measures after use. An analysis feature can flag anomalies, trends and potential drivers; an analyst still validates each finding and decides what happens next.
Request the vendor's attestations and confirm what they cover. A SOC 1 report covers controls relevant to your own internal control over financial reporting, while a SOC 2 report covers security, availability, processing integrity, confidentiality or privacy. A Type 2 report adds an opinion on whether those controls operated effectively over a period. None of them is a blanket answer: the report has to cover the product and the hosting environment you will rely on.
Implementation effort depends on your data more than the software. BARC's implementation research reports that 80% of companies take between one and twelve months from purchase to initial rollout of planning, and the state of your data usually decides where in that range you land.
The other variable is who does the work. When you buy through an ERP reseller or implementation partner, the partner's staffing matters as much as the product. Support after go-live is where projects most often come up short, so agree on a longer, outcome-based hypercare period before you sign. In one Microsoft transition-to-support case study, hypercare hours meant to last four to six weeks ran out within two.
Ask each partner these questions:
A disciplined process protects you from a polished demo. Run it in five steps:
Weight usability, performance, integration and scalability above a long feature list. The weights below are a starting point to adjust for your priorities:
|
Criterion |
Weight |
|
ERP and Industry solutions data connectivity |
25% |
|
Ability to build and change models in-house |
20% |
|
Planning, reporting and consolidation coverage |
20% |
|
Implementation effort and partner support |
15% |
|
Data model, detail and scale |
10% |
|
Security, controls and AI governance |
10% |
Then compare total cost of ownership over three to five years, not the subscription alone. Count these cost lines:
Most failed selections trace back to a handful of avoidable errors:
Solver is an AI-accelerated extended financial planning and analysis (xFP&A) platform for mid-market teams. The platform covers planning (budgeting and forecasting), reporting, consolidation and analysis in one multi-tenant cloud on Microsoft Azure.
Solver Copilot includes AI capabilities, such as the Help Agent and the Analysis Agent. The Help Agent gives users step-by-step guidance drawn from the platform's help, support and training content, while the Analysis Agent can identify anomalies, trends and potential drivers; users can easily validate each finding and decide what to do next. It runs on OpenAI GPT models inside a Microsoft Azure environment under SOC 2 controls, never uses user input to train the models, and works within each user's existing report permissions. The platform can be implemented in multiple ways, including Solver Consulting, self-paced training through Solver Academy, or through a global network of trusted ERP partners who know your industry.
Before your first demo, pick one real report and one budget form, write down how long each takes your team today, and ask your ERP vendor or partner for a walkthrough that rebuilds both on your own data.
To prepare for those walkthroughs, download the Guide to Choosing the Best Extended Financial Planning and Analysis (xFP&A) Solution.